Hans-Christoph Steiner @eighthave@librem.one

And that concludes my reporting on the #DMAWorkshop, thanks to the Filecoin Foundation for the Decentralized Web #FFDW and their grant to @guardianproject for paying my way. https://www.ffdweb.org/guardian-project-annoucement/ - https://f-droid.org/en/2022/02/05/decentralizing-distribution.html

Congrats to #matrix co-founder @matthew for rocking the last #DMAWorkshop, there was still quite a bit of buzz about how the live bridging demo carried a ton of weight, despite the lobbying efforts from #Meta, you can see it at around 14:00 in the live stream recording https://webcast.ec.europa.eu/dma-workshop-2023-02-27

Very exciting to hear the #EuropeanCommision say it is clear that the #gatekeepers are not the only ones who are providing secure and trustworthy app stores. I think that comment alone has made my trip worthwhile #DMAWorkshop

Rupprect Podszun said it is clear after today that there will be changes to the fee structures of app stores. #Google disagrees that there will be changes in the fee structure, and instead offers: "there will be more workshops". So is this a "kill the design by putting it to endless committee discussions"? #DMAWorkshop

Interesting comparison between #Google vs #Apple approaches at #DMAWorkshop. They have very different methods of gatekeeping, and #Android has been typically quite a lot more open #iOS. And Google has already added some improvements for other app stores. Google says, "hey, we're already trying to find ways to comply" while Apple seems to stick to its guns: "our way is the only way to trusted app stores."

The Open Web group is quite passionately advocating for putting web apps and #PWA on equal footing. While I do agree to some extent, I think there are key technical details that mean web apps will always be more dangerous for privacy and user control than native apps. Web apps are harder to review because their source can change per-user, per-visit, etc. #DMAWorkshop

App stores are certainly a lot more than just payment clearing services for selling apps. #DMAWorkshop

@ilumium finally got #FreeSoftware in the discussion: #Apple is not the only one who can run an app store well. And they didn't even invent app stores, but instead, that came from #GNULinux distros at least a decade earlier. #DMAWorkshop

#Apple's representative gave a classic, well polished FUD PR piece framed as lots of questions. Of course, I fully agree that human review of apps is key to trustworthy app stores, that's why #FDroid goes the whole way and requires apps provide the whole source code to be review, not just the binaries. And F-Droid does done this since 2010 even though #FDroid is not a #gatekeeper. Being the only app store on the platform locks out app stores that do better review than #apple. #DMAWorkshop

#FreeSoftware was almost mentioned at #DMAWorkshop: one key point was that mobile operating systems in 2008 were in a race to get developers. #iOS and #Android were tiny newcomers with no developers. The idea from app stores came from free software and hackers. #Debian APT started in the 90s, #Cydia was on iOS when #Apple was still saying web apps were the only way. And of course, #Android used #OpenSource as a key strategy to get #developers interested in their platform.

I love that Martijn Snoep, the Dutch regulator, used the term #DarkPatterns, that gives me hope that this regulation can be effective. #DMAWorkshop

The #gatekeepers have huge resources as compared to the regulators, so regulators must be strategic and pool resources. Also, communities based on tracking and reviewing the actions of the #gatekeepers can also play a role here. #Developers know the APIs they have to work with, and can report fishy business. Bloggers can report on key technical details that steer things towards the #gatekeepers. #Hackers can show when things ate technically possible, despite what #gatekeepers say. #DMAWorkshop

Time to change my lingo, I've been saying #monopoly. At the #DMAWorkshop the talk is always about #gatekeepers. It is a clearer analogy.

Gene Burrus again raises a key point. Platform companies change APIs frequently as a method to deliberately disadvantage other developers, forcing them to play catch up to have a good user experience. #DMAWorkshop

Fully support the question from uptodown.com: file formats matter, #Android App Bundles (AAB) vs APKs give #GooglePlay a big wedge to disadvantage other app stores. #Google is good at turning small technical improvements like that into tools to maintain their #monopoly. There are other ways to solve the problem of smaller APKs. This one happens to preference Google Play, since control that format and require it. Plus they require developers give their private key to Google Play #DMAWorkshop

Great point from Gene Burrus: #Microsoft's #monopoly was broken via regulation, and that meant that #Google and #Apple were not charged a 30% fee as they worked to break into the market that had been dominated by #Microsoft. The DMA is building on that experience. #DMAWorkshop