Follow
Is “Animal Rights” a Real Thing ?
In this post which we are publishing for further discussion, Stratton J. Davis argues that the idea of animal rights is incompatible with an ordered, civilized society.
https://indianlibertyreport.com/is-animal-rights-a-real-thing/
@wizzwizz4 its an interesting topic and tbh we’ve not made up our minds either !
@ilr I really don't like this article, though. Its arguments seem deliberately flawed. It even equates killing and eating livestock to finding a lost dog – these are not the same thing, but the argument both relies on and implies that they are.
Somebody who believes what they're arguing for does not argue in this way.
@ilr This argument is building from flawed premises:
* One must be an agent to have rights.
* Something either has rights, or does not have rights.
* All agents are perfectly rational with perfect information.
It also makes unjustified assertions (perhaps true? 😞):
* One must eat meat to not starve.
* Unclaimed land is unused.
* If an animal is not owned by a human, it will be harmed by other humans.
* Animal behaviour is incompatible with humans treating them as having rights.