Every time Mozilla steps on a rake regarding privacy or security, people come rushing out telling everyone to switch to Firefox forks. And I always feel bad about it, because if your main concern is privacy or security, there is no scenario where you would be better off on a Firefox fork

"Explain." OK.

1) No Firefox fork is doing large-scale engineering work on the browser. They're all small teams whose main contribution is things like different configuration settings. If Mozilla dies, these forks will all die too.

2) Some forks consider it a feature that they keep old, insecure APIs Firefox itself abandoned because they could not be secured (NPAPI, XUL, etc.) Mozilla could not secure these APIs; forks aren't going to be able to. Most don't bother trying.

3) You're still running on Mozilla code, so your trust model still includes Mozilla. Now it just also includes a third party. Do you trust them? Why?

Show thread

@jalefkowit i really feel uncomfortable seeing people recommend LibreWolf left and right to everyone as if it was a perfect drop-in replacement for everyone using Firefox

It's very much not

Most users will get a broken experience out of the box and will need to undo a lot of the config changes provided by LibreWolf to use the browser normally

At that point simply what's the point? You can just as well apply a custom configuration to your Firefox installation

Follow

@rail_ @jalefkowit Tried Floorp as a drop in replacement and similar to firefox and librewolf as a user you still have to change pretty much ~100-200 settings so it wont ping back to the mothership (google, mozilla). In that sense they are all still very much the same as Firefox. It would be great if these alternatives actually configured it such way to take mozilla and google 100% out of the loop (changing default search to duckduckgo only doesnt count)

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Librem Social

Librem Social is an opt-in public network. Messages are shared under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license terms. Policy.

Stay safe. Please abide by our code of conduct.

(Source code)

image/svg+xml Librem Chat image/svg+xml