Someone starts a new #FOSS project as a hobby activity. "No one bossing me around like at work, just having fun, do as I wish." they write in the README.

After some time the project starts to get noticed, people request new features, and some Pull Requests are contributed and merged. There's a good vibe with similarly interested devs.

One year later. An unhappy community has formed. People complain about the #BDFL and harsh words circle the social channels.

Is the label of "BDFL" justified?

@smallcircles Every developer whose decisions are not based on democratic voting is a BDFL. At least, that's the way I intuitively understand the term. Also, I'm not aware of any projects that are not led by dictators or oligarchs.

@pixelcode

If that were true, it wouldn't seem attractive to me to expose my pure hobby project codebase as #FOSS.

#BDFL is a loaded term. It conveys a commitment, and moral and ethical duties. And that for your hobby project, you bestowed as a gift to others, so they might also have fun with the code.

Follow

@smallcircles @pixelcode
Is it such a common term these days? I'm of course familiar with it, but in abbreviated form it still confused me, I even had to look it up πŸ˜…

Β· Web Β· 1 Β· 0 Β· 0

@m0xee @pixelcode

Not so much a common term but a common model that people use in practice for their #FOSS project. Without realizing it often, they get into this #BDFL "zone" and then have to deal with the consequences.

There's a lifecycle for FOSS projects, that encompasses more than coding and CI.

At Social Coding movement I defined a term for this: The Free Software Development Lifecycle (FSDL) that takes this explicitly into account.

discuss.coding.social/c/sx/fsd

@smallcircles @pixelcode
Oh… Yep, I remember the term back from the days when Guido van Rossum was appointed as one (and didn't mind much), I suppose much of this theory didn't exist at the time (yet).
Thanks for the link, I'll look into it!

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Librem Social

Librem Social is an opt-in public network. Messages are shared under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license terms. Policy.

Stay safe. Please abide by our code of conduct.

(Source code)

image/svg+xml Librem Chat image/svg+xml