Instagram’s upcoming Twitter competitor shown in leaked screenshots. Supports ActivityPub, eh? Wasn't expecting that theverge.com/2023/6/8/23754304

Follow

@mlabowicz People keep saying this whenever there's mention of a major implementation of activitypub, but I really fail to see what the extinguish part is supposed to look like.

People on the rest of the fediverse won't go anywhere if this takes off - if anything, they'll have increased incentives to stay where they are as there are more people to follow. If this service became popular and then dropped support, at worst it would just leave the fediverse exactly as it was.

@sab As far as I'm concerned I'm just happy they don't opt for Bluesky.

@sab @mlabowicz I'm spitballing here, but would it look like this: extend means adding features, which would incentive people to switch to their instances. A suitably devious adversary, comparable to Microsoft of the 90s, for example, would create many instances and then use them & top notch new features to attract people while simultaneously penalizing regular instances, say by ingeniously corrupting, or adding latency to, responses to them. I'm sure all sorts of mayhem could be caused.

@sab @mlabowicz they slowly infiltrate standards boards, decision making committees, gradually as features that sounds great, and nobody realizes until years later that the changes oblige other instances do implement something to keep up and interoperate which leaves them wide open to something like a copyright infringement suit, which the adversary uses to get them all shut down.

@sab @mlabowicz In some office somewhere, someone is being assigned a budget of tens of millions to bring this about, or something like it. Their retirement plans hinge on it, and they absolutely will not stop, ever, until the fediverse as we know it is dead.

@tartley If they manage to add features and trick people into joining their instances before locking them in, wouldn't it be easier to just launch services with said features and trick people into using their services right away? At which point it's just the status quo?

For me, email seems a better comparison (even though everybody's tired of it). Gmail might be monopolistic and awful, but nothing done by Google, Yahoo, Microsoft, or anyone else managed to destroy it.

@sab having lived through jabbers rise and fall, I hope I'm wrong. Maybe the fediverse is already well enough established to avoid the same fate

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Librem Social

Librem Social is an opt-in public network. Messages are shared under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license terms. Policy.

Stay safe. Please abide by our code of conduct.

(Source code)

image/svg+xml Librem Chat image/svg+xml