@jonathan @cstross

Public Service info from the volunteer chief archivist at datamuseum.dk:

NEVER use flash-based storage for archival purposes.

Not CF, not SD, not USB-sticks, not SSD, not NVME, nor any other flash-technology based storage media.

Flash is simply not a stable storage mechanism: Just like Dynamic RAM it will eventually forget your bits.

Unfortunately there are no good choices for long term data storage, but flash is a particular bad choice.

@larsbrinkhoff @bsdphk @jonathan @cstross care to elaborate? All I heard is that it is the "best" option.

@ekg @bsdphk @jonathan @cstross Lots of tapes written long ago are hard to read today. Often they flake apart, so you only get one chance of recovery.

@larsbrinkhoff @ekg @jonathan @cstross

In datamuseum.dk we have approx 80% luck with ½" tapes, and very very bad luck with ¼" cartridges.

Also troublesome: Hard disks from 1990 forward.

@ekg @bsdphk @jonathan @cstross tape degrades horribly. And the read and write process are pretty physically aggressive.

@ttmevans @bsdphk @jonathan @cstross long term storage doesn't necessarily imply read and write cycles, quiet the opposite.

@ekg @bsdphk @jonathan @cstross Sure, but over time the media of tape degrades and the extra contact the read heads can put extra stress on an already weak media.

I do remember some WORM media designed for archival back in the 90s, but I don't know how stable it was over other optical media.

@ekg @ttmevans @jonathan @cstross

Actually it does:

The only way to preserve data long term, is to have many copies and periodically check that they can be read, and to keep copying to fresh media periodically.

@bsdphk @ekg @ttmevans @jonathan @cstross Yep, that's the only reliable way. It also gives you a chance to see if the format is still easily readable.

@ekg @ttmevans @jonathan @cstross

The only reasonably reliable data storage we know of, is paper tape.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Librem Social

Librem Social is an opt-in public network. Messages are shared under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license terms. Policy.

Stay safe. Please abide by our code of conduct.

(Source code)

image/svg+xml Librem Chat image/svg+xml